loader image
Close

Emigration Canyon Home Owners Association

"The ECHO-Association"

Skip to content
  • About
    • The ECHO-Association
    • Emigration Canyon, Utah
    • EID Trustees
      • Michael Scott Hughes
      • Fred A. Smolka
      • Brent Tippets
      • David C. Bradford
      • Lynn Hales
      • Mark H. Stevens
    • Simplifi Company (Public Water System Operator)
      • Deputy Mayor Jennifer Hawkes
      • Eric Hawkes
    • Emigration Canyon Mayor & EID Operations Manager Joe Smolka
    • EID & Simplifi Company Legal Counsel
    • EID Advisory Members
      • R. Steve Creamer
      • Walter J. Plumb III – City Development Inc.
      • Kem C. Gardner – The Boyer Company L.C.
      • Lynn Hales
      • Steve Hook
    • EID Independent Contractors
      • EID Trustee Chairman Fred A. Smolka
      • Mayor Joe Smolka
      • Deputy Mayor Jennifer Hawkes
      • Eric Hawkes
      • Bill Cutting
    • Emigration Canyon Metro Township
      • Mayor Joe Smolka
      • Deputy Mayor Jennifer Hawkes
      • Rick Raile
      • Steve Hook
      • Gary Bowen
    • Emigration Canyon Community Council
      • Michael Scott Hughes
      • Lynn Hales
      • Paul Brown
      • Gary Bowen
    • Emigration Canyon Planning Commission
      • Brent Tippets
      • Lynn Hales
    • Land-Developer R. Steve Creamer
    • Land-Developer Walter J. Plumb III
    • Land-Developer Kem C. Gardner
    • Emigration Oaks PUD
  • Water Contamination
    • ECHO – Community Press Release
    • EID & Boyer Testing Violations
    • Federal Safe Drinking Water Act Violations
      • EID – Failure to Report Water Testing Violations
      • EID – Misrepresentation of Lead Contamination
      • EID – Falsification of Public Records
    • Lead Contamination
      • Laboratory Test Results
        • Table of EID Water Sources & Customers
        • Source – Upper Freeze Creek Well
        • Source – Brigham Fork Well
        • Source – Boyer Well Nr. 2
        • Source – Boyer Well Nr. 1
        • EID Water Distribution Lines
        • Homes – 2020 (Nov)
        • Homes – 2020 (June)
        • Homes – 2019
        • Homes – 2017
        • Homes – 2016
        • Homes – 2013
        • Homes – 2010
        • Homes – 2007
        • Homes – 2004
        • Homes – 2001
        • Homes – 1998
        • Homes – 1997
        • Homes – 1996
        • Homes – 1995
        • Homes – 1994
        • Homes – 1993
    • Copper Contamination
      • EID Contamination Notice
      • Actual Copper Contamination Test Results
      • Copper Contamination Map
    • Radioactive Contamination
    • Bacterial Contamination
    • Turbidity Contamination
    • Sulfate Contamination
    • Antimony Contamination
    • TDS Contamination
    • Possible Sources of Drinking Water Contamination
      • Disposal of Construction Waste by Land-Developer Creamer
      • EID Water Sources
      • EID Water Distribution System
      • EID Water Treatment Facilities
      • EID Water Storage
  • Water Litigation
    • Current Status
    • Ground Collapse / Stream Depletion / Drinking Water Contamination in Emigration Canyon
      • Groundwater Mining – Sierra de Crevillente Aquifer, Spain
      • Groundwater Mining in the United States
      • Groundwater Mining – Cedar Valley, Utah
      • Groundwater Mining – Emigration Canyon
        • Fissures and Ground Subsidence – Aerial Recording
        • Overbuild of Emigration Canyon
        • Loss of Artesian Pressure in Emigration Canyon
        • > USGS – Groundwater in Utah
        • > 1966 Utah State Engineer Study
        • > 1988 Utah State Freeze Creek and Boyer Well Investigation
        • > 1995 Barnett Testimony – Stream Impairment
        • > 2000 Barnett-Yonkee Study – Groundwater Mining
        • > 2008 USGS Report – Emigration Canyon Stream Contamination
        • > 2015 Hansen Report – Emigration Canyon Stream Depletion
        • > 2018 Salt Lake City Testimony – Private Well Impairment
    • ∎ Supreme Court of the United States (False Claims Act)
      • Overview
      • Press Release
      • Third Amended Complaint
      • Supporting Documents
        • ECHO – Letter to Salt Lake County
        • Refusal to Certify Use of Federal Funds – Onysko Memorandum
        • Declaration – US ex rel. Tracy
        • Declaration – EID Trustee Bowen
      • ∎ Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS)
        • 10th Cir. Order & Circuit Split
        • Amendments, Studies & Case Law
        • SCOTUS Application
    • ∎ California Court of Appeals for the Sixth District
      • Appellant – Opening Brief
        • Complaint
        • Appellant Mark Christopher Tracy – Opening Brief
      • Defendant Gardner – Response Brief
      • Appellant – Reply to Defendant Gardner
        • Appellant Tracy – Reply Brief
      • Kinghorn Defendants – Response Brief
      • Appellant – Reply to Kinghorn Defendants
        • Appellant Tracy – Reply Brief
      • Default
        • Entry of Default Judgment – R. Steve Creamer
    • ∎ United States Congress (Mt. Olivet Cemetery Water Rights)
      • ECHO – Petition for Judicial Review
      • ECHO – Protest (SLC)
      • ECHO – Congressional Letter
    • ∎ United States 10th Circuit Court of Appeals (Civil Rights Act)
      • ECHO – Civil Rights Complaint
      • ECHO – Opening Brief
      • Simplifi – Response
      • Bennion – Response
      • ECHO – Reply Brief
    • ∎ Utah Supreme Court (Lead Records)
      • USA ex Rel. Tracy – Petition for Judicial Review
      • ECHO – Petition for Writ
      • Utah Supreme Court – Order
    • ∎ Utah Supreme Court (Groundwater Mining)
      • USA ex rel. Tracy – Petition for Judicial Review
      • USA ex Rel. Tracy – Petition for Writ
      • Utah Supreme Court – Order
    • ∎ Utah Supreme Court (Request for Public Records)
      • USA ex Rel. Tracy – Petition for Writ
      • Judge Kouris – Notice of Nonresponse
      • Utah Supreme Court – Order
      • ECHO – Motion to Reinstate
    • ∎ Utah Court of Appeals (Fire Flow Testing)
      • SRC – 1st Decision and Order
      • SRC – 2nd Decision and Order
      • ECHO – Opening Brief
      • EID – Response Brief
      • ECHO – Reply Brief
    • ∎ Utah Court of Appeals (500+ New Homes)
      • ECHO – Petition for Judicial Review
      • ECHO – Opening Brief
      • Defendant Hawkes – Motion to Dismiss Appeal
      • ECHO – Opposition to Motion
      • EID – Response
      • State Engineer – Response
      • ECHO – Reply
    • ∎ Utah State Third District Court (Lead Records)
      • Utah Third District Court – Order
    • ∎ Utah State Engineer (69 New Homes)
      • EID – Extension Request
      • ECHO – Protest
    • ∎ Utah State Engineer (Crombie/Jimenez)
      • ECHO – Protest
      • ECHO – Second Protest
      • State Engineer – Order
      • ECHO – Reconsideration Request
    • ∎ Utah State Records Committee (Legal Invoices)
      • ECHO – GRAMA Request
      • ECHO – First Revised GRAMA Request
      • ECHO – Second Revised GRAMA Request
      • ECHO – Third Revised GRAMA Request
    • ∎ Utah State Records Committee (Hawkes and Hall Emails)
      • ECHO – GRAMA Request
      • ECHO – GRAMA Appeal
    • ∎ Utah State Records Committee (Water Lease Payments & Water Letters)
      • ECHO – GRAMA Request
      • ECHO – SRC Appeal
      • ECHO – Status Request
    • ∎ Utah State Records Committee (EID Trustee / Advisory Committee Emails)
      • ECHO – GRAMA Request
      • ECHO – SRC Appeal
    • ECHO – Independent Engineer Report (EID Water Rights)
    • ECHO – Independent Hydrology Report (Well & Stream Impairment)
    • ECHO – Declaration Mark Christopher Tracy
    • ECHO – Declaration Former EID Trustee Bowen
    • EID – Misrepresentation of Water Capacity
    • EID – Falsification of Public Records
    • EID – Undisclosed Water Source Problems
    • EID – Misrepresentation of Fire Protection in Emigration Canyon
    • EID – Misrepresentation of Hydrological Studies and Water Right Priority
    • Cohne Kinghorn P.C. – Misrepresentation of EID Water Rights
    • EID – Denial of Permanent Changes to Water Rights
    • EID – Denial of Future Planned Development
    • EID – Denial of Stream Impairment
    • EID – Denial of Ground Water Impairment
  • New Members
    • Guide to Member Benefits
    • Open Membership Enrollment
    • Membership Application
    • Membership Deadline
    • Membership Fees
  • Members
    • Members Falsely Promised Water Service by EID
    • Members Forced to Abandon Private Wells
    • Members Paying EID Standby Fees
    • Members Suffering a Loss of Water Service
    • Members Suffering Contaminated Drinking Water
    • Members Suffering Contaminated Private Wells
  • News
  • Info
    • ECHO Administration
    • Request Free Drinking Water Testing
    • Test for Lead Poisoning
    • Lead & Copper Filters & Test Kits
    • Report Private Well Depletion
    • Report Loss of EID Water Service
    • Report Ground Subsidence
    • Report Foundation Damage
    • Register for Email Updates
    • Direct Contact Link
    • Make an Appointment

Kinghorn Respondents’ Consolidated Response Brief

 

Download Kinghorn Respondents’ Consolidated Response Brief
Kinghorn Respondents’ Appendix (Volume I)
Kinghorn Respondents’ Appendix (Volume II)
Kinghorn Respondents’ Appendix (Volume III)
Respondents Consolidated Brief (stamped)

Proudly powered by WordPress